Home » Herbal Medicine » Why See a Medical Herbalist When Your Tests Say You’re Fine?

Last Updated on November 7, 2026 by Nikki Hawkes

Why See a Medical Herbalist When Your Tests Say You’re Fine?

by | Oct 5, 2026 | Herbal Medicine

Summary

You can feel unwell and still be told that everything’s normal. It might be tiredness that doesn’t lift, bloating, broken sleep, brain fog or thinning hair. Your doctor may want to rule out anything serious first. If your blood tests come back normal or nearly normal, the next step is often to keep an eye on things. That can leave you without an explanation for how you feel. This post explains where a medical herbalist fits in, and what a ninety minute appointment and a full case history can add.

Key takeaways

  • Your own account of what’s been happening is often the most useful information. In one study, it explained the problem in 76 per cent of cases.
  • Telling your whole story takes more time than the average UK GP appointment, which is less than ten minutes.
  • A normal test result is reassuring, but it doesn’t always mean your levels are the best they could be for you.
  • Several small changes, looked at together, can point to one underlying cause.
  • A medical herbalist takes a full case history, which is why your first appointment is a long one.

The gap between feeling unwell and being told you’re fine

Most of us know the feeling of leaving an appointment with “everything’s normal” and no idea what to do next. You may still be tired, and still be bloated by four o’clock. But nothing was found, so it can feel as though there is nothing to do.

When tests come back normal or nearly normal, nothing has been found that needs medical care. Working out why you still feel below your best is a different kind of work. It takes a different kind of appointment, and that is what a medical herbalist is trained to offer.

Why finding a cause takes a longer appointment

GP appointments in the UK are short. One review of consultation times across 67 countries put the average UK GP appointment at less than ten minutes.

Looking for an underlying cause means asking what came first, what else has changed, and how the parts of your story connect. That takes much longer than ten minutes, so the parts of a story often get heard at separate appointments, or not at all. It may be why you feel you’ve tried everything and still want to know what’s going on.

Where the answer usually is

The most useful information in any consultation is usually in the story you tell. Researchers followed 80 people attending an outpatient clinic with a new problem. The history alone gave the answer in 76 per cent of cases. Physical examination added another 12 per cent, and laboratory tests added 11 per cent. Those tests also ruled other possibilities out, and made the doctors more confident in what the history had suggested.

The history matters so much because it gives the order of events. It records what came first, what followed, what makes things better or worse, and what else changed at the same time. A blood test gives a number for one day, whereas a history covers months or years.

Tests are useful, and they tell you most when they are read alongside a full history.

Why a normal result isn’t always an optimal one

Standard testing is designed to find illness. Clinical chemists set a laboratory reference range as the central 95 per cent of a reference population. The top and bottom two and a half per cent fall outside it, and those are the results that get flagged. In other words, the range is a statistical boundary drawn around a group of people. It shows whether you are far from the average, but it doesn’t show whether your level is the best one for you.

So a result can fall comfortably inside the range and still be lower than it was for you five years ago. Or it can be at the very edge of the range, in the direction that fits everything else you’re describing. Both come back marked normal, because the range is there to flag results outside it.

I wrote about this in more detail in why blood tests alone won’t tell you what you need. A result only means something when it’s read alongside your history, diet and the pattern you’re noticing.

Signs that cluster, and why a checklist separates them

Health problems can come several at a time. A study of 1.75 million patients in Scotland found that nearly a quarter were living with two or more long-term conditions. And more of those people were under 65 than over it. You may recognise a smaller version of that, with several things going slightly wrong at once.

Here is one example of what a group of signs might mean. Take bloating after meals that builds through the day, tiredness by mid afternoon, thinning hair, and iron and B12 at the low end of normal. Each of those can be looked at on its own, and each can have a reasonable explanation.

Read together, those four things can point to low stomach acid. Stomach acid is part of how protein is broken down and how iron and B12 are taken up. Researchers reviewing long-term use of acid suppressing medicines report effects on the absorption of B12, iron and magnesium. Low stomach acid, whatever the reason for it, makes the same job harder.

Food that isn’t properly broken down ferments lower in the gut, which can be what lies behind the bloating. Poor iron uptake can leave you tired, and it can affect your hair as well. It’s a connection that is easy to miss when each sign is looked at separately. I’ve written about how low stomach acid affects digestion and absorption and why too much and too little acid can feel the same.

That is only one possibility, and it won’t be the explanation for everyone with that set of signs. Sometimes it’s the thyroid, sometimes it’s the way meals are spaced, and sometimes it’s two things overlapping. But the pattern only becomes visible when all of your signs are looked at together, in the same appointment.

The question a herbalist is asking

Herbal medicine starts with what set a problem off and what is keeping it going. That is the main difference between herbal medicine and conventional medicine. A painkiller is aimed at the pain, and an antacid is aimed at the burning. Herbal medicine considers why the pain or the burning is there in the first place. If the cause is still there, the problem tends to come back once you stop taking the remedy. So the first thing I want to know is why the problem started.

Medical herbalists are trained to look for the underlying causes of problems so they can be addressed. My page on herbal medicine and herbalism explains what that training covers. Looking for the cause comes before choosing any remedy. Finding it takes a full case history, the training to read it, and the time to do both properly. That’s the whole reason the first appointment is long. I have written more about why finding the root causes matters.

The herbs are chosen differently too. If you buy a herb for yourself, you usually pick one that is sold for your problem, such as a sleep tea for poor sleep. A herbalist chooses herbs for you as a whole person. That means looking at your digestion, sleep, stress load, the medication you’re already taking, and what your body has been doing for the last two years. What you leave with often has several parts. There may be a blended tincture alongside simpler things, such as a tea for the evening, capsules, a cream, a tonic for when you’re frazzled, or bitters before meals. Each part is chosen for you. So you and a friend with the same complaint may leave with different recommendations. I’ve explained more in do herbal medicine remedies actually work.

What a first appointment with me involves

Taking your history is the part that takes the most time, so the first appointment in my practice is ninety minutes. Before it, you complete an intake form, send any recent test results, and keep a food diary for three consecutive days. I ask for at least one weekday and one weekend day, because the two rarely look alike. The difference is often where the useful detail is.

The form means we don’t spend the appointment on dates and medication lists. Having your test results means I can read them against your story and not on their own. And the food diary shows me what you actually eat and when. That tells me more about your digestion, energy dips and sleep than any single question could.

By the end of that first appointment, you may have heard a connection between things you’d been carrying as separate problems. Patients often describe that moment to me afterwards as “why hasn’t anyone told me that before?” Ninety minutes and a full case history are what make it possible.

Why the follow-up matters as much as the first appointment

The first appointment involves looking for the pattern, and the follow-ups are where the support is adjusted to how your body responds. That takes more than one visit. A review of 13 studies on continuity of care looked at what happens when people keep seeing the same doctor. In nine of the twelve studies that measured it, those people had lower mortality. That research was done in general practice, but the reason behind it carries across to any clinical relationship. A practitioner who knows your story from the start is more likely to notice when a change occurs.

In herbal practice, the second and third appointments are generally where your herbs are adjusted. A herb that was right for the first six weeks may need to change, for instance as your digestion improves or your sleep gets better. That adjustment is part of the work. My patients usually have around three follow-ups over five or six months.

Where this leaves you

You may have several changes in your health that haven’t been explained, each one looked at individually and suggested to be nothing much. If so, it may be that they haven’t yet been looked at together. The history is where most answers are found. A normal result means you fall inside a statistical range. And signs that cluster often share a cause.

A medical herbalist is trained to look for that cause, to match the support to you, and to adjust it as your body responds. That’s what a consultation is for. And if you keep asking “I just want to know what’s going on”, a full case history is the place to start. If you have already tried everything, I have written about why nothing seems to work.

Related to this post

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Nikki Hawkes Medical Herbalist and Functional Medicine Practitioner

Nikki Hawkes

BSc.Hons, PG.Dip

MNIMH, MCPP

Nikki Hawkes holds a BSc (Hons) in Phytotherapy and a Postgraduate Diploma in Nutritional Medicine. She is a registered member of the National Institute of Medical Herbalists (MNIMH) and the College of Practitioners of Phytotherapy (MCPP). Both require degree-level entry. With over 20 years of clinical experience, she also holds certification as a Functional Medicine Health Consultant. Her practice combines traditional herbal medicine with current research in nutrition and functional medicine.