Summary
Switchel is an old farm drink made from apple cider vinegar, ginger, honey and water. It was drunk in the hay fields to keep workers going through long, hot days. Britain has its own older relative, the oxymel, a mix of honey and vinegar that herbalists have made for centuries. This post explains what the ginger and vinegar do for your digestion and blood sugar. It also covers what switchel can do for hydration. At the end is a simple recipe you can keep in the fridge.
Key takeaways
- Switchel is a mixed drink, and it isn’t fermented. The vinegar in it is the fermented ingredient.
- Ginger has a long traditional use for bloating, wind and a poor appetite.
- In a trial, ginger helped the stomach to empty twice as fast after a meal.
- Vinegar taken with a meal lowered the rise in blood sugar afterwards across many human trials.
- Its vinegar and honey carry only traces of minerals, so switchel mainly helps you to drink more water.
- Drink it diluted, or through a straw, to protect your teeth from the acid.
A cold glass of something sharp and gingery at the end of a warm afternoon is a very old pleasure. Switchel was made for exactly that, and its roots in herbal medicine go back much further than the farm. Its two working ingredients, ginger and vinegar, both have something to offer your digestion. Below you’ll find what each one does, what the research shows, and how to make a jar at home.
What switchel is, and its British cousin the oxymel
Switchel is a traditional drink from North America, often called haymaker’s punch. Farm workers drank it at haymaking to keep going through the heat of the day. The recipe is simple: apple cider vinegar, fresh ginger, water and a sweetener such as honey, maple syrup or molasses. It tastes tangy, sweet and warm all at once. You can serve it cold over ice, or warm in winter.
You’ll sometimes see switchel described as fermented, but it isn’t. The ingredients are simply stirred together and left to steep. It’s the vinegar that is fermented, because it is made in two stages. Yeasts first turn the sugars in apple juice into alcohol. Then acetic acid bacteria turn that alcohol into acetic acid. I cover which fermented foods are worth buying in my post on fermented foods and your gut.
Here in Britain, we have an older relative of switchel called an oxymel. The name comes from the Greek for sour and honey. An oxymel is honey and vinegar mixed together, often with herbs steeped in it. Its use in medicine dates back to Hippocrates, and it was used in the medicine of medieval Britain. Researchers who went through 418 medieval remedies for infections found vinegar, honey or oxymel named 151 times. Those recipes were written in Old English, Middle English, Latin and Welsh, between the ninth and fifteenth centuries. Herbalists still make oxymels today, because honey and vinegar carry the taste of bitter or pungent herbs well. An oxymel is taken by the spoonful, while switchel is diluted to drink by the glass.
Ginger for your digestion
Ginger is a warming digestive herb with a very long history of use. Its European herbal monograph records its traditional use for bloating, wind and mild spasm in the gut. It also records its use for a poor appetite and for colds, and its well established use for travel sickness. The warmth you feel from ginger comes from its pungent compounds, the gingerols and shogaols. Traditionally, that warmth is used to get a sluggish digestion moving again, especially in cold, damp weather.
That traditional use has been tested in people. In a trial in 24 healthy volunteers, ginger capsules taken before a meal made the stomach empty twice as fast. The stomach also contracted more often than on a placebo, and that is how it moves food on. So, if you often feel full and heavy long after eating, ginger has long been used for exactly that. Across 16 trials in 1,010 people, ginger also lowered C-reactive protein, a blood marker of inflammation. I cover that in my post on anti-inflammatory herbs and spices. You can read more about ginger and peppermint together in the best herbs for digestive health.
Vinegar and your blood sugar after meals
After a starchy meal of bread, pasta or potatoes, your blood sugar rises over the following hour or two. A sharp rise and fall can leave you tired and hungry again soon after eating. That pattern can be familiar after 40. Vinegar taken with the meal can make that rise smaller. That effect has been measured in people many times over.
In one Swedish trial, healthy volunteers ate white bread with three different amounts of vinegar, or with none. The more vinegar they had, the lower their blood sugar and insulin were 30 minutes later. They also felt fuller. This year, researchers pooled ten meta-analyses covering 38 trials. Vinegar lowered blood sugar after meals by around 0.8 mmol/L. It lowered fasting blood sugar and HbA1c, the three month average, as well. A glass of switchel holds less vinegar than many of those trials used. So, drinking a glass with a starchy meal is a gentler version of the same idea.
But, as a cautionary note, if you already take glucose-lowering medication, vinegar can add to its effect. A medical herbalist can look at how the two fit together for you. You can read more in my posts on gut health and insulin resistance and walking after meals.
Raw apple cider vinegar is often sold with “the mother”. This is the cloudy mat of cellulose and bacteria left from making it. Many people choose it for its fuller flavour. A recent review found little research on live vinegars so far, so what the mother adds is still unclear. Either raw or filtered vinegar makes a good switchel.
Switchel for hot days and hard work
Switchel is often called nature’s sports drink. Most of its value for hydration comes from the water in it. The flavour makes it easy to drink more than you would of plain water. Apple cider vinegar and honey both contain minerals, but only in small amounts. Apple vinegar holds up to about 195 mg of magnesium per litre. So, a glass of switchel gives you around 2 mg. Honey is mostly sugar and water, with only traces of minerals.
When you sweat, the main mineral you lose is sodium, and switchel contains very little of it. After a long, hot day or hard exercise, a pinch of salt in the jar helps to replace some. For an ordinary day, switchel is a flavourful way to drink more. The honey does add some sugar, so topping a glass up with sparkling water makes it lighter. I cover how much fluid you need in how much water to drink a day.
Homemade ginger switchel recipe
This makes about 900 ml, enough for five or six glasses. The jar is already at drinking strength, so there is no concentrate to measure out.
Ingredients
- 60 ml (4 tablespoons) raw apple cider vinegar
- 60 ml (4 tablespoons) runny honey, or maple syrup
- 15 to 30 g fresh ginger, about a thumb to two thumbs, grated
- ½ teaspoon ground chilli, if you like some heat
- 800 ml cold water
- Ice, and sparkling water if you like it fizzy
Method
- Put the vinegar and honey in a large jar and stir until the honey dissolves. A splash of warm water helps if your honey is thick.
- Add the grated ginger, and the chilli if you are using it.
- Pour in the cold water and stir well.
- Cover the jar and leave it in the fridge for at least two hours. Overnight gives a stronger ginger flavour.
- Strain out the ginger.
- Pour about 150 ml over ice and drink it as it is. For a lighter, fizzy glass, top it up with 50 to 100 ml of sparkling water.
- Keep the jar in the fridge and drink it within a few days.
Each 150 ml glass holds about two teaspoons of vinegar and two of honey. Vinegar is an acid, so it can soften the enamel on your teeth over time. Drinking it diluted, or through a straw, helps to protect them. If you have reflux, an acidic drink can make it worse for some people, so start with a small glass. Honey should not be given to babies under one year old, because it can occasionally cause infant botulism.
Ways to vary your switchel
- Spring: add a few sprigs of lemon balm and a squeeze of lemon while it steeps.
- Summer: muddle in a handful of strawberries and some fresh mint.
- Autumn: add a cinnamon stick and a splash of apple juice.
- Winter: warm a glass gently with extra ginger and a star anise, and drink it as a hot drink.
Frequently asked questions
Is switchel fermented?
Switchel isn’t fermented. It’s a mixed drink, made by steeping ginger in vinegar, honey and water. Only the vinegar in it has been fermented.
What does switchel taste like?
It tastes sharp, sweet and gently spicy, a little like a ginger lemonade with more tang. The longer the ginger steeps, the warmer it becomes.
Is switchel good for digestion?
Ginger has a long traditional use for bloating and wind. In a trial, it helped the stomach to empty faster. Vinegar with a starchy meal lowered the rise in blood sugar afterwards in many human trials.
Does switchel replace electrolytes?
It replaces very little. Vinegar and honey hold small amounts of minerals, and switchel contains almost no sodium. A pinch of salt in the jar helps after heavy sweating.
Can I drink switchel every day?
You can drink it daily, diluted, as part of what you drink across the day. Drink it through a straw if you’re concerned about your teeth. If you take glucose-lowering medication, bear in mind that vinegar can add to its effect.
What is the difference between switchel and an oxymel?
An oxymel is a stronger mix of honey and vinegar, usually with herbs in it. It’s taken by the spoonful. Switchel is diluted with water to drink by the glass.
Where this leaves you
Switchel is a simple drink with a long line of herbal medicine behind it. Ginger warms and moves a sluggish digestion, and vinegar with a meal can soften the rise in your blood sugar. The water does the hydrating, and the flavour makes it easy to drink more of it. A jar in the fridge takes five minutes to make and lasts a few days.
Bloating, a heavy feeling after meals or dips in energy often have more going on underneath. If talking through what might lie behind them sounds helpful, you’re welcome to book a free hello call.
















0 Comments