Home » General Health » Finding the Root Causes: Why a Health Problem Keeps Coming Back

Last Updated on October 17, 2026 by Nikki Hawkes

Finding the Root Causes: Why a Health Problem Keeps Coming Back

by | Mar 17, 2025 | General Health

Summary

When a health problem keeps coming back, it is usually because what set it off is still there. This post explains why I look for the cause behind a problem rather than the problem alone. It explains why most long-standing health complaints have more than one cause, and how those causes feed each other. It uses digestion as the example, and it ends with what a consultation with me involves.

Key takeaways

  • A remedy aimed at the problem itself can ease it, but if the cause is still there the problem tends to return.
  • Long-standing health problems rarely have one cause. They usually develop through several factors that keep each other going.
  • In digestion, the usual causes are low stomach acid or digestive enzymes, foods that do not suit you, a change in your gut bacteria, stress, and hormones.
  • Two women with the same complaint can have different causes, so they need different herbs.
  • Breaking the cycle means working on more than one point in it, in a sensible order, not all at once.
  • Finding the cause takes a full case history, and that is what a consultation with a medical herbalist is for.

Have you ever found something that helped, only for the problem to come back when you stopped taking it? A tablet eases the bloating or the burning, so you take it, it settles, and then a few weeks later you are back where you started. That is not a failure on your part. It is what happens when a remedy is aimed at the problem itself and not at what is causing it. It is a bit like turning off the smoke alarm without putting out the fire.

There is a place for quick relief, and sometimes you need it to get through the day. But if you want the problem to stop coming back, there is a question to answer first, which is why it is happening at all. This post is about that question. It explains why I look for the cause, why there is usually more than one, and how I go about finding them.

Why the cause matters more than the complaint

Take bloating as an example. An over the counter remedy can ease it for an afternoon. But the bloating may be there because a particular food does not suit you. It may be there because your gut bacteria changed after a course of antibiotics, or because you are under a lot of strain. The remedy has not touched any of that. So the bloating comes back, and it will keep coming back until the cause is dealt with.

Looking for the cause takes longer at the start. It needs patience, experience and sometimes a bit of detective work. But it is the part that leads to lasting improvement rather than a problem that is patched up for a while. It also tends to reduce how much you need to take in the long run, because you are no longer treating the same thing over and over.

Why there is rarely one cause

When someone comes to me with gut health issues, it is rarely just about the digestive system. Sleep, stress, past infections, what she eats, her hormones and many other things may all be playing a part. That is because most long-standing health problems do not have a single cause. They develop through a web of factors that keep each other going.

Imagine a woman with ongoing tummy pain and bloating. It began after food poisoning upset the balance of bacteria in her gut. Now she struggles to digest certain foods, which makes the discomfort worse. Because she is uncomfortable she does not sleep well and feels more stressed, and that makes her digestion worse again. When digestion is not working well, her body cannot take in all the nutrients it needs, so she is tired, and that can affect her hormones too.

Can you see how one thing led to another in a circle? That is why dealing with one part of it, such as taking digestive enzymes for the bloating, might help a bit but will not undo the whole cycle.

The trouble with looking for a single cause

Medicine has often looked for one cause and one answer, and sometimes that works well. Stomach ulcers are a good example of both what it gets right and what it misses. Forty years ago ulcers were treated with medication to reduce stomach acid. It helped, but the ulcers came back once the medication stopped. Then two researchers found a bacterium, now called Helicobacter pylori, in the stomachs of almost every patient with an ulcer. Treating the bacterium cleared many ulcers for good.

Even that was not the whole story, though. More than half the people in the world have this bacterium, and most of them never develop an ulcer. So something else decides who does, and stress, diet and inheritance are all thought to play a part. One cause was found, and it still took more than one factor to produce the problem.

In my practice, I’ve seen this repeatedly. Different women with identical IBS complaints can have completely different causes behind them. One developed the problem after antibiotics changed her gut bacteria. Another has a food that does not suit her and is causing inflammation. A third has digestion that has slowed under long-term stress. Each of them needs a different approach, even though what they describe sounds the same.

The usual causes behind digestive problems

Every woman’s situation is her own, but certain patterns come up again and again when digestion has been a problem for a long time.

The digestion itself may not be working well. That often means too little stomach acid rather than too much, which surprises many people, or too few digestive enzymes, or not enough bile. I have written about low stomach acid separately, because it comes up so often.

A food may not suit you. Unlike an allergy, which happens at once, a food intolerance can be delayed and subtle, so it is hard to spot without looking for it properly. Gluten, dairy, eggs and soy are common ones, but an intolerance can develop to almost any food, especially when the gut is already irritated. The difference between the two is explained in my post on food allergy and food intolerance.

Your gut bacteria may have changed. The trillions of bacteria in your gut help with digestion, with your immune system and even with your mood. Antibiotics, illness, diet and stress can all change the balance between them, and that change shows up in how you feel. If a course of antibiotics is where your trouble started, my post on restoring gut health after antibiotics explains what happens.

Stress reaches your gut directly. Your gut and brain talk to each other constantly through the vagus nerve. So a stressful period changes how much acid and enzyme your stomach makes, how fast food moves through you, and how well the gut lining holds together. I have explained each of those in stress and stomach problems.

Your hormones are involved too. Oestrogen, progesterone, thyroid hormones and cortisol all affect how your gut works. That is why many women notice their digestion change across their cycle, and again as their periods change. There is more on this in how menopause affects the gut.

Breaking the cycle

A common cycle goes like this. Digestion is not working well, so fewer nutrients are absorbed. That lowers energy and makes stress harder to cope with, and the stress then makes digestion worse again. Round it goes.

Easing the digestion on its own gives temporary relief but does not break the cycle. What does is finding the points where it can be interrupted. That might mean supporting digestion directly, replacing nutrients that have run low, calming the stress response, and supporting the gut lining or the bacteria that live there. Working on several points usually does more than working on one.

That does not mean doing everything at once. Changing everything together is overwhelming, and it makes it impossible to tell what is helping. It means a thought out order, one step building on the last. And it takes patience, because a problem that has built up over months or years rarely goes in a fortnight. Small, consistent steps last longer than dramatic changes that cannot be kept up.

Why your plan has to be yours

There is no protocol that fits everyone, so I build the plan around you. That means your own history and how the problem developed. It means which factors seem to be driving it in your case, how your body has responded to things you have tried before, and what is realistic in your life right now.

The order matters as much as the contents. If broken sleep is wearing you down, that may need attention before any big change to your diet. It is hard to change how you eat when you are exhausted. If you are under severe strain, that comes before anything demanding. Getting the foundations in place first gives everything else something to stand on.

Progress is not usually a straight line, either. There are ups and downs as your body adjusts, and that is normal. The aim is not perfection but improvement that holds, because the things that were actually driving the problem are being dealt with.

What this looks like in a consultation

Medical herbalists are trained to look for the causes of ill health, and that is what the first appointment is for. It is 90 minutes long because a full case history takes that long to do properly. I want to know when the problem began, what was happening in your life at the time, what else changed, and what you have already tried. Your digestion, sleep, energy, hormones and stress all come into it, because each one affects the others.

Herbs suit this way of working well. They can be chosen and combined for the particular causes behind your problem, and adjusted as things change. So two women who come to me with the same complaint will usually leave with different prescriptions, because the reasons behind their complaint are different. You can read about what happens in a herbal consultation before you decide.

Where this leaves you

When you understand what is driving a problem, you gain more than relief from it. You start to recognise your own patterns, and you learn what helps you and what sets you back. That knowledge stays with you.

If you have had a health problem for a long time, it may be that the cause has not yet been looked for. That is especially true of a digestive problem that has come back despite everything you have tried. If any of this sounds like it might be helpful, you are welcome to book a free hello call and tell me what has been going on.

Related to this post

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Nikki Hawkes Medical Herbalist and Functional Medicine Practitioner

Nikki Hawkes

BSc.Hons, PG.Dip

MNIMH, MCPP

Nikki Hawkes holds a BSc (Hons) in Phytotherapy and a Postgraduate Diploma in Nutritional Medicine. She is a registered member of the National Institute of Medical Herbalists (MNIMH) and the College of Practitioners of Phytotherapy (MCPP). Both require degree-level entry. With over 20 years of clinical experience, she also holds certification as a Functional Medicine Health Consultant. Her practice combines traditional herbal medicine with current research in nutrition and functional medicine.